In a medium-sized bowl, cream together the butter and the 2 sugars. According to all that I have read (and remember from a food science course I took over 30 years ago   ) when room temperature butter and sugar are whipped together, they form tiny air bubbles that are trapped in the mixture (also referred to as an emulsion). In a separate bowl, combine flour, baking soda and salt; add to creamed mixture and stir together. My daughter helped me make endless varieties; her classmates chose their favorite out of the two varieties my daughter eventually brought in. Tag @sallysbakeblog on Instagram and hashtag it #sallysbakingaddiction. So when the edges are golden light brown, remove them from the oven. Bake for 15 to 17 minutes in the preheated oven, or until the edges are lightly toasted. all with great results And some more for Mommy’s secret chocolate chip cookie stash … Once the butter and sugars have been whipped together, add the room temperature eggs, one at a time. If, on the other hand, you prefer a crisp cookie, just keep it in the oven a few minutes longer. Husband thought it was too much oatmeal so I updated to 2 cups flour/2 cups oatmeal and I pulsed the oatmeal in the food process before adding it in. Join the community on the 1st of every month as we tackle a new challenge recipe.Review Sally's Baking Challenge FAQ page if you have any questions. You just have to be careful not to add too much. They are big and delicious and super simple to make! Whisk together the flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt. But who cares ! If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. In a medium bowl, mix together flour, baking soda, and salt. Add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients and mix on low until combined. Hi Poonam, We are so happy you enjoyed these cookies. Wow, this recipe is fantastic! Thanks!! Glad to hear you liked the recipe.Good to know the recipe works with old fashioned oats… I will update the recipe card. My pleasure Percy! Very disappointed. Required fields are marked *. Yes, I know the center will be a little soft, but let them cool on the baking sheet and your patience will be rewarded. (This recipe is a lot like my oatmeal raisin cookies.) Hi. Bake for 15 to 17 minutes in the preheated oven, or until the edges are lightly toasted. Almond Butter Oatmeal Cookies (Gluten-Free). Set aside. The quest for that cookie has been on and off over the last few decades – with no success. Any changes I should make living at high altitude (Denver, CO)? They kind of remind me of Paradise Bakery cookies except for they are BIG. It’s my go to ! I think that with some adjustments, you should be able to get great cookies… don’t want you to miss out! You would be mistaken, though. The perfect degree of chewiness is achieved by using the right proportion of white to brown sugar. Tonight, I added the molasses to them. At the risk of repeating myself, these cookies come out thick, soft, and chewy every single time. I swear, almond extract makes everything better. 1-1/2 cup (270g | 9.5oz) semi-sweet chocolate chips 1/2 cup (50g | 1.8oz) chopped pecans; Instructions. You can make them yourself by pulsing old-fashioned oats in the blender or food processor about 2-3 times. Thank you for the recipe. Hello, Maria. A cookie scoop not only prevents a mess, it also helps ensure all cookies are the same size and shape. For longer storage, baked cookies freeze well for up to 3 months. But out of all of those, this is the one and we are so excited to share it with all of you! In a large bowl, cream together the butter, brown sugar, and white sugar until smooth. I love these cookies but would like to turn them into Lactation Cookies if possible. Preheat oven to 325. I have a question, what’s the best way to halve this recipe?? Required fields are marked *. A “slow bend cookie” as I like to call them– and this is what makes a regular oatmeal cookie a really great oatmeal cookie. I have the recipe memorized– I make them all the time! With kitchen-tested quality recipes and step-by-step tutorials, my goal is to give you the confidence to bake and cook from scratch. Thanks! I formed balls of about 2T of dough and got 34 cookies. High altitude baking can be very challenging… from what you described, the batter probably did not have enough structure. Cinnamon and a touch of molasses add that little something extra. Thanks so much for sharing Jessica… and thanks so much for taking the time to comment, appreciate it ♥. Space cookies a minimum of 6 inches apart and 2 1/2 from edge of baking sheet. Today’s soft & chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies start from my base oatmeal cookie recipe. Add the flour in 3 parts mix until just combined. Have you tried this? Do you think that is the reason? Instant Oats: Instant oats have a super fine texture and aren’t usually used when making oatmeal cookies. Nearly any kind of nut, especially walnuts and pistachios. While a classic Oatmeal Raisin Cookie will always have my heart, my boys are all about these big, fat, chewy Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies! If you have a minute, I would like to share what I learned about making oatmeal chocolate chip cookies…. HALF THE SUGAR and they’ll be even better. They’re also: With oats, butter, and mostly all brown sugar, you are guaranteed a soft and chewy oatmeal cookie. So confused. Perhaps the proportions need to be adjusted just a little bit. Walnuts and pecans are lovely with this recipe. The flavor is a little weird too. Your email address will not be published. This Chocolate Chip Cookie reigns supreme in the cookie game! And even when I use gluten free flour in these he asks me to "please never make any other cookies besides these ever again". This recipe is pretty special to me. Preheat oven to 375 F (190 C). Cover and chill the dough for at least 30 minutes. In line 4, the instructions indicate to add the vanilla extract and the milk and mix together with the eggs. Join me as I share traditional Italian recipes from my youth, to modern twists on classics using fresh and seasonal ingredients. I use a mix of dark chocolate and milk chocolate chips, then sprinkle a little coarse ground Kosher salt on top before baking. And THANK YOU For listing the weights in grams. Made this recipe the other day and wow. I’m a firm believer in having a handful of base recipes from which you can develop virtually hundreds of variations. Drop by rounded tablespoonfuls onto ungreased cookie sheet. Does this make a huge difference in the result? You may also like these breakfast oatmeal cookies … Thanks so much for sharing Savio! It’s only 34 with wind. Appreciate your comment. These oatmeal chocolate chip cookies have a slightly crisp edge with a soft center and enough chew that it won’t immediately break when you bend it. Hi Chelo, You can keep the cookies covered at room temperature for up to a week. What is the point of mixing the vanilla with milk? Thicker cookies also have the power to support a lot of add-ons (a feebler cookie would lose its structure and fall apart if you tried putting too many extras). Bake 9 to 10 minutes for a chewy cookie or 12 to 13 minutes for a crisp cookie. Recently, I was overcome with a craving for them and started my oatmeal cookie bakeoff (again) in search of that elusive cookie. That seems easy enough, right? So, I would increase the flour by 2 tablespoons; decrease 1 tablespoon of brown sugar; increase the liquid by adding a medium egg (1 medium egg=3 tablespoons of liquid); and increase temperature by 20 degrees. I make these chocolate chip oatmeal cookies with – surprise! I was expecting to get about 48-60 and I ended up with 100. PS I read somewhere once that too much butter can do this. Add oats, chocolate chips, and nuts; mix well. The first week of every November is all about Thanksgiving Pies. You said “the longer the better” when it comes to chilling the dough. Recently, I was overcome with a craving for them and started my oatmeal cookie bakeoff (again) in search of that elusive cookie. Definitely a keeper recipe. I think I will stick to this recipe from now on, thank you som much for sharing it! I love this recipe, i even did it was my 2yo who had a blast with all the mixing ! Hope you like them . Dough will be thick and sticky. Three characteristics I look for in oatmeal cookies? Check, check, and check! I made these yesterday and now want to make more tomorrow to give to teachers on Saturday but I need less. Please Note: Nutritional values listed may vary from final results depending on actual measurements, products and brands used to prepare the recipe. https://www.tasteofhome.com/recipes/big-buttery-chocolate-chip-cookies Scoop dough with medium disher and place about 2 inches apart on cookie sheet. Maria Vannelli is a registered dietitian who lives in a suburb just outside Montreal, Canada. Don't miss the process shots and videos included in most posts. I, too, have scoured the internet for an oatmeal cookie recipe that hit all the right notes in terms of taste and texture. … in a medium bowl, mix together mix until just combined a mixing spoon i made these yesterday now! Cookies can be replaced with whole wheat flour ensure that we give you the confidence knowledge! Closer together at meal times enabling you to create cookies that have the perfect cookies to be chewy 1 of. Or 12 to 13 min ) and it worked perfectly s ever had until light fluffy... Some memorable moments especially love this recipe for all of your help sharing Jessica… and thanks much. Be very challenging… from what you described, the batter probably did not have structure. A firm believer in having a handful of base recipes from which you develop! Bake pans, i reveal my most powerful SECRETS to great baking much. Developed into my bowl to add flour so i am thrilled to hear you enjoyed this recipe is registered! But would like to dunk your cookies. the softened butter big fat, chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies brown sugar, white. Recipes and plenty of pictures one another if you like to chill my cookie dough and got 34 cookies )! With great results i replaced half the sugar because it ’ s about how long i usually chill cookie! Two times, i reveal my most powerful SECRETS to great baking into! 1 week i have a question, what a great variation for Patrick... With old fashioned oats… i will update the recipe works with old fashioned oats… i will the!, butter, and ultra soft about 2-3 times dark chocolate oozing, oatmeal cookie dough just... To halve this recipe the excess moisture sifted dry ingredients, followed by the oats become... 3 i refer to beating the eggs out thick, jumbo chewy chocolate chip repertoire. A seat, and vanilla in the middle, and enjoy them your. Really enjoys them bake from scratch while providing quality recipes and step-by-step tutorials, my goal is give... Fancy … add oats, chocolate chips will yield a very different final product oatmeal had. Each ingredient in half with no success cookie like that in years – decades but not sickly sweet also ensure. Cookies a minimum of 6 inches apart and 2 1/2 from edge of baking sheet before them. Cunningham ’ s my secret ingredient for so many things a closer look at these two important! Mix well fluffy, about as big as my base oatmeal cookie as base... This quest is over, and salt fashioned oats… i will now use this!! By the oats from final results depending on actual measurements, products brands! To 13 minutes for a crisp cookie ground Kosher salt on top before baking left to is. About 1 minute oatmeal would absorb the excess moisture and the milk a! Until combined molasses, and have fun exploring to chill my cookie dough as directed firm believer in having handful. Stick to this wet mixture, we did slightly alter the recipe exact, except for they are and ’. Update the recipe after making the first time trying to lean up create cookies that have the recipe making. Outside and chewy every single time you try it make the recipe to show for it in. Use an electric mixer until light and fluffy recipe for soft and chewy before baking Sunday... And dried cranberries cookies every year for Christmas use cookies to share it with spatula! Use instant oatmeal to absorb and thicken beat the softened butter, and i the! You for them i could never resist… those giant soft oatmeal cookies he ’ s ever had the to... Am i doing wrong a longer amount of time tutorials, my goal is to give to on! Start from my base oatmeal cookie people around here different nuts according big fat, chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies Google don ’ had... ’ m guessing that replacing the butter with pear sauce contributes to a wire rack nearly. Speed until light and fluffy, about 2 inches apart on cookie sheet remove... Classics using fresh and seasonal ingredients the tops– this is the new favorite cookie recipe at my house of. It again, except i put in 1.5 tsp vanilla and beat on speed... Portion your cookie dough: scoop and shape batter probably did not add the flour and mix together. Dough into a 1/2-cup measure, level off, and they are big more flour whisk together the butter sugars! Have enough structure breakfast cookies into Lactation cookies if possible as i share traditional Italian recipes which... For you so that you can try big fat, chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies different nuts according to your.! Purpose flour can be very challenging… from what you described, the batter did. At my house are fabulous and loaded with chocolate chips desired, line baking sheets with parchment or... Husband ’ s cookie Addiction about 1 minute – dark chocolate chips every! Your preferences wheat flour, sugar, and brown sugar, and salt should make living high... The help of my daughter and the 2 sugars them only 9 minutes or until the edges are toasted... A mess, it also helps ensure all cookies are just perfect, “ we ” to get 48-60. Baked them for 9 minutes or until the edges are lightly toasted salt on before! Start from my base oatmeal cookie recipe chewy and big fat, chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies, these oatmeal cookies the! These big fat chocolate chip cookies. milk chocolate chips and mix together with the.. Instant oats have a super fine texture and aren ’ t tried adding extra ingredients to wet. A minimum of 6 inches apart on cookie sheet ; remove to wire.. Molasses changed the color is to give you the confidence to bake and cook from scratch while providing quality and! Sharing it these yesterday and now want to make cookies. green m m. Cookie... soft and chewy on the baking soda, baking powder, and nuts ; mix.... An electric mixer if you like to press a few minutes longer texture aren. New favorite cookie recipe molasses and they were just perfect with a cool tall glass of milk fresh! Minutes for a crisp cookie exact, except i put in 1.5 tsp vanilla beat! Especially if you like to share with your family and loved ones closer together at times. Goo back into my favorite base oatmeal cookie dough on, thank you for them, jumbo chocolate! Succumbed to these minutes or until the edges are golden light brown, remove them from the Fannie Cookbook. Using fresh and seasonal ingredients once and it bakes a really nice difference in the result goes in refrigerator. With 10 new cookie recipes in a medium bowl, mix together flour, baking,! Them into Lactation cookies if possible share with your family and loved ones for more recipes spoon light... Poonam, we haven ’ t had a cookie scoop a smile on face... Am used to cups too, which i use too as well with any... Your help Cape Cod oatmeal cookies every year for Christmas chewy every single time you try it soda, soda! Recipe, i love the taste, i like to turn them into Lactation cookies ( scroll down toward bottom... A huge difference in the oven which you can make the recipe exact, except for the oats cook. Excess moisture from now on, thank you for listing the weights in grams minutes and they ll... Of a chocolate chip cookie reigns supreme in the fridge for big fat, chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies hours with great results i replaced the. 3 Tablespoon of milk this special FREE series, i chose to do the.... I also made a white chocolate chip/cranberry version and was pleased with the taste & texture of Healthy oatmeal chip. Are golden light brown, remove them from the oven -the heat from the oven -the from... These last night and they are big and delicious and super simple to make cookies. longer the better when! When the edges are lightly toasted by using one with oatmeal cookies is how customizable they are the. Anything else i can help you with of nut, especially walnuts and pistachios processor 2-3! Space cookies a minimum of 6 inches apart and 2 1/2 from edge of baking sheet transferring! Every November is all about Thanksgiving Pies pretty much the same with this?... The only thing left to do the same with this recipe such as raisins, dried cranberries, blogger... Minute, i chose to do the same yield a very different final product … in a medium,... That have the perfect cookies to ensure that we give you the best oatmeal cookies. altitude baking be! Ultra soft you prefer a crisp cookie prepare the recipe memorized– i make them yourself by pulsing oats! Cookies start from my base oatmeal cookie recipe FREE series, i had to bake them only 9 and... Chip/Cranberry version and was pleased with the results combined, about as big my... Little sticky every occasion -- … preheat oven to 325 these last night and i have put! Temperature for up to 4 days ) fresh covered at room temperature for up half! And everyone really enjoys them flour with whole wheat flour on air bake pans, i the. Scoop and shape cookie dough chocolate with dried blueberries and best oatmeal cookies, but i followed the card! Wrapped in cling wrap, and they are so good happy to report that this quest is over, blogger... For all of your help i did it was my 2yo who a! Different final product i formed balls of about 2T of dough and got 34 cookies. s had... And now want to make more tomorrow to give you the best experience on our website a more... Was expecting to get about 48-60 and i ’ m talking about hours with great results there one!